Make "" your Homepage! | Add to Favorites | RSS | About us English | فارسی | Russian - english edition
/Home/ Analysis/

Bargain over troop withdrawal from Afghanistan - 20.2.2012
Dmitry Verkhoturov

Bargain over troop withdrawal from Afghanistan

By Dmitry Verkhoturov, expert at the Centre for Contemporary Afghan Studies.

Early February of 2012, two significant events occurred. Firstly, Moscow-based daily “Komercant” reported about talks between Russia and NATO on the creation of a transit hub on the Russian territory where military cargo of the foreign contingent in Afghanistan would be reloaded into trains to transport them to Riga or Tallinn, the ports of NATO member-states. According to preliminary reports, the hub will be set up in Ulyanovsk which has the best facilities for reloading.

Secondly, reportedly, U.S. State Department has temporally lifted sanctions imposed on Uzbekistan after the events in the city of Andijan in 2005 on supplying military aid to the country until September 2013. The U.S. believes that it’s possible to supply ammunition, night vision equipment, GPS equipment and other outfits necessary for defence and law enforcement agencies.

This is not the first time that sanctions imposed against Uzbekistan were lifted. In October 2009, the European Union lifted sanctions against Uzbekistan ending an arms embargo imposed after the events in Andijan in 2005. The reasons for the move have been improvements in the human rights situation and the release of some political prisoners. EU foreign ministers said the aim was to further encourage the Uzbek authorities to move towards democracy.

In short, Uzbekistan has long fumbled its behaviour towards the European and American partners, which is based on bargaining. A bargain starts when the EU, the U.S or NATO needs something from Uzbekistan, for example, its airbases, land transit routes, some political moves or definite position on economic issues, and during this process, the Uzbek authorities are trying to win one concession after another.

Notably, though this strategy is unpleasant, it has helped to achieve good results. For one, within four years, Uzbekistan got rid of all sanctions imposed against by the EU over the events in Andijan. Moreover, it has long been a NATO partner and has enjoyed the right to choose the level of this partnership. We have seen several forms of this partnership within the 10 years of foreign military presence in Afghanistan. In this issue, Uzbekistan is confidently using the changes in the situation around Afghanistan and NATO agreements with other countries for its benefit, and this makes it possible for the country to become the key link in the transportation of NATO cargo from Afghanistan through land routes. This has predetermined Uzbekistan’s good starting position in the forthcoming troop pullout and military cargo withdrawal.  

At present, Uzbekistan has not only a transit railroad of 1520mm gauge, which paves the way for the transportation of cargo directly to the NATO member states, Latvia and Estonia, but also a railroad extended up to Mazar-i-Sharif in the Afghan territory. “O’zbekiston Temir Yo’llari” company built this rail road and enjoys the right to exploit it temporarily.  The first trains made their trial rides along the new railway.

This allows the NATO command in Afghanistan to set up a network of terminals which will receive cargo from all bases across the country, sort out them and load into trains. Despite the fact that land route through the CIS countries, including Russia is the longest, nevertheless, it is the safest one. No one will launch attacks on it, and there is no possibility of damaging or losing cargo.

The Uzbek route has become crucial after Pakistan closed key route used to supply cargo to the NATO contingent in Afghanistan. Relations between Pakistan and the U.S. have cooled down owing to several reasons: the death of Pakistani servicemen after NATO air attacks, the American raid to kill Usama bin Laden in Pakistan without notifying the Pakistani Government or army in advance about the operation and attempts to organize talks with Taliban in Qatar. Pakistan is not only losing the status of an American ally but also is losing important levers that can exert influence on the situation in the region.

In December 2011, American servicemen abandoned the Shamsi Air Force Base in Belujistan to meet Pakistan’s demand and Islamabad refused to receive a visit to Pakistan by the American special envoy to Pakistan and Afghanistan, Mark Grossman. Washington gave tit for tat and in December 2011, US Congress decided to freeze $700 financial aid to Pakistan.

Consequently, relations between the U.S. and Pakistan can be currently described as very tense. Despite many statements that have been made by both the U.S. and Pakistan they have been restored, the relations will hardly return back to the previous level of partnership in the near future. Most likely, NATO troop withdrawal will be carried out without the active involvement of Pakistan. Moreover, Taliban militants operating along the Pakistani route might launch attacks on convoys and destroy cargo.

Interestingly, Pakistan decided to worsen its relations with the U.S. despite the threat that it might loose American aid. This specifies the circumstance that another participant in regional politics is backing Pakistan, and it is very powerful and can compensate for possible loss. This is, of course, China which has promoted cooperation with Pakistan and Afghanistan. The withdrawal of American troops is in principle in the interests of China which will get an opportunity to strengthen its influence on the region and actively develop mineral resources in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Worsening relations with the U.S. drags Pakistan into the sphere of China’s influence because it has no other country to rely on for help.

In these circumstances, what happened in early February 2012 shows that at present, new political situation is taking shape under which NATO forces will be pulled out from Afghanistan. This is not only an agreement on transit, which might change unexpectedly, but also in general, the establishment of relations in the region during the pullout and afterwards.

/Latest publications/
12.12.15 Afghanistan will buy 150 thousand tons of natural gas from Azerbaijan
4.12.15 Russia will supply 10 thousands AK assault rifles to Afghanistan
1.12.15 Chairman of Afghan Meshrano Jirga discussed security problems with Valentina Matvienko
24.11.15 India will send Afghanistan some Russian helicopters
23.11.15 Afghan ecologists are upgrading their skills in Volgograd
23.11.15 Nursultan Nazarbayev held talks with Afghanistan President in Astana
23.11.15 Afghanistan and Turkmenistan agreed on trade and economical cooperation
5.11.15 Russian Ministry of Defense is concerned about IS fighters presence in the northern Afghanistan
5.11.15 “Al-Qaeda” worries about Russian fight with Islamic State group
5.11.15 Russian envoy in Kabul hopes to renew cooperation with NATO in Afghanistan
29.10.15 Mi-35 delivery proposal resulted in pro-Russian sentiments growth in Afghanistan
29.10.15 Vladimir Putin expressed his condolences to Afghanistan and Pakistan
27.10.15 Zamir Kabulov: Russian government is able to communicate with “Taliban”
27.10.15 Russian Ministry of Emergency Situations is ready to help Afghanistan after recent earthquake
19.10.15 MoF of Russia: ISIS could use Afghanistan to find way into China and CIS countries
19.10.15 MoF of Russia: delay of USA forces pullout from Afghanistan demonstrates their campaign failure
19.10.15 Dr. Abdulla: Afghanistan welcomes Russian help against terrorism
17.10.15 Vladimir Putin expressed dismay at growing terrorists’ influence in Afghanistan
17.10.15 Alexander Mantytsky: Russia could help Afghanistan to fight terrorism
17.10.15 Russia is ready to supply Afghan aviation with helicopters
11.10.15 International conference devoted to Afghanistan security threats continues in Moscow
11.10.15 Afghanistan and Russia talked over further economic cooperation
11.10.15 Russian and Tajikistan presidents discussed Afghanistan security problems
7.10.15 Zamir Kabulov: USA failed to train Afghan security forces properly
7.10.15 Abdul Rashid Dustum visited Grozny to meet Ramzan Kadyrov
7.10.15 Russian MFA condemns NATO aistrike at Kunduz
30.09.15 Famous photo “Afghan girl” by Steve McCurry will be displayed at the Hermitage
21.09.15 Alexander Mantytskiy: Russia calls for joint anti-terrorism efforts in Asian region
17.09.15 Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation calls for more efforts in Afghanistan
16.09.15 Vitaliy Churkin: “Islamic State” controls part of drug traffic from Afghanistan
16.09.15 Afghan delegation visits Moscow to discuss further economic cooperation
15.09.15 Collective Security Treaty Organization is concerned about “Islamic State” presence in Afghanistan
10.09.15 Hamid Karzai reflects on his presidency
8.09.15 Russia will help Afghanistan to maintain Mi-8 helicopters
7.09.15 Abdul Rashid Dustum seeks for Russian support to handle regional problems
12.09.13 Putin, Karzai to discuss military technical cooperation on sidelines of SCO
10.09.13 Afghanistan needs support from international community
9.09.13 Russian Foreign Ministry condemns NATO attack killing Afghan civilians
9.09.13 Afghanistan and Russia pay tribute memory of Ahmad Shah Masood
8.09.13 Afghan immigrants follow Russian language courses free-of-charge in Stavropol
11.07.13 Azerbaijan, Afghanistan discuss bilateral cooperation
11.07.13 Turkmenistan, Afghanistan sign agreement on gas supply
5.07.13 Americans to continue fighting terrorism in Pakistan
21.05.13 Terrorist attack masterminded in Afghanistan and Pakistan averted in Moscow
20.05.13 Afghanistan plans to buy Russian planes for army
20.05.13 Russian forces in Tajikistan will not guard border with Afghanistan
10.05.13 Most influential politicians in Afghanistan: April 2013
28.04.13 Almaty hosts Istanbul Process Conference
28.04.13 Kazakh President rejects possible negative developments in Afghanistan
24.04.13 Russia-NATO Council discusses corporation on “helicopter package”
Copyright © 2006 All rights reserved. Contacts